Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Hugh McCarthy's avatar

I think you are being harsh on Malhotra and Bhattacharya. Whilst what you and Sonia say is correct, Bhattacharya stood up at the start when nobody else was. It is true he believed Covid was dangerous for over 50s and thought the vaccine was a good thing for that age group—but he opposed compulsion, masks, school closures, business closures, travel bans and mandation. Malhotra has admitted his mistake over and over again and nearly from the start highlighted the role of big pharma in medical training and regulation.

It is hard to believe that neither sought to clarify if covid was deadly, if it existed, if the vaccine was needed and if it worked.

The proof of the pudding will be if they effect change, but one must recognise the size of the task for as you know this is deeply embedded in institutions.

I would rather have them than others—having shared platforms and articles with them I feel they are more genuine than most-even if the dream team has seemed to change its position.

Expand full comment
4 more comments...

No posts